Staying on the right side of copyright

This project lets you back up the Sonoff firmware on a plug you own, and put it back later. Sonoff’s firmware is Sonoff’s copyright, so this page sets out what the project does, and deliberately does not do, to keep that use lawful. It is not legal advice.

The short version

• The backup is of your plug, is kept on your computer, and is only ever written back to the same plug.
• The project never distributes Sonoff’s firmware, in whole or in part.
• The tool updates through the plug’s ordinary update mechanism, started from your own eWeLink account. It breaks no encryption, signature or other protection.

What the law allows

Copyright law in most places lets the lawful user of a program make a backup copy of it, and study how it works so that other software can work with it:

• UK: the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, s.50A (backup copies), s.50BA (observing, studying and testing) and s.50B (decompiling for interoperability).
• EU: the Software Directive 2009/24/EC, Art. 5(2), 5(3) and 6. The backup right cannot be removed by contract.
• US: 17 U.S.C. §117, which lets the owner of a copy of a program make an archival copy. Firmware that comes with a device you bought is generally treated as a copy you own.

None of these rights cover giving the copy to anyone else, and that is where the line is drawn below.

Right-to-repair laws mostly require manufacturers to provide parts, tools and information. They support what this project does, but they do not grant copyright permissions, so the project relies on the copyright exceptions above.

What the project does

The backup stays with you and your plug

• The backup is read from the plug during a conversion and saved under captures/plugs/<MAC>/sonoff-backup/ (Your Sonoff backup). captures/ is Git-ignored, so a backup cannot be committed by accident.
• Each backup is filed under the MAC address read from the chip’s own eFuses, not one reported over the network.
• Back to Sonoff’s firmware only writes a plug’s own backup to that plug, and is only offered when that backup is on the computer doing it. It is never used to put one plug’s firmware onto another. Each backup also holds that plug’s eWeLink device id and keys, which belong to that plug alone.
• The backup is written once and kept read-only. Converting a plug again keeps its first backup.

No Sonoff firmware is distributed

• No Sonoff firmware image, and none of Sonoff’s code, is in the repository or its history. The firmware files committed are this project’s own builds, builds of Tasmota and ESPHome, and two data files (THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md lists their sources and licences).
• One of those data files, artifacts/sonoff-s60-partition-table.bin, was read from a stock plug. It is the standard ESP-IDF partition table every S60 ships with: a short, fixed-format list of partition names, offsets and sizes, with no code or settings in it. The tool needs it to check that a plug’s layout is the one it expects, and to put that layout back when a plug returns to Sonoff’s firmware.
• The docs describe the firmware format in prose and tables. They do not list Sonoff’s code or data.
• The emulator (emulator.md) boots your own backup, and its image does not contain one. tools/emulator/patch_stock.py changes a copy of your backup so it runs under QEMU. It checks the bytes it replaces are as expected, but carries none of Sonoff’s code beyond those few instructions, and never changes the backup itself.
• The emulator’s public plugs, which test the firmware a conversion ends on, hold nothing of Sonoff’s: they are made from plugs past the point where Sonoff’s firmware has been replaced, and tools/emulator/sanitise_plug.py shows each holds no part of the backup it came from (emulator.md).
• The maintainer keeps their own backup off their computer, as any owner may back up their own: encrypted on their side, in a private package only they can reach, never in the repository, a release or anything public (private-backup.md).

Nothing is circumvented

The tool does not ‘get around’ technological protection measures.

• It sends the plug the same kind of upgrade command Sonoff’s servers send, from the plug owner’s own eWeLink account. The plug runs every check it normally does, including the SHA-256 check on the firmware it downloads (How it works).
• The plug’s firmware is not encrypted and does not check signatures, and the tool does not disable or work around any such feature.
• The optional router rules (router-rules.md) keep a stock plug as it is by stopping it from installing updates. They do not defeat anything.

Signing in to eWeLink

• The tool signs in to eWeLink as you, with your own account, to talk to your own plugs. It does not keep your password or the access token (How your eWeLink account is handled).
• The application id it signs in with is the public one used by the open-source SonoffLAN integration. It is not taken from Sonoff’s own app.

Names

Sonoff and eWeLink are trademarks of their owners. The project names them only to say which devices and services it works with, and states that it is independent and not an official installer (THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md).

What we ask of you

• Do not share your backup. It is Sonoff’s firmware, and it also holds your Wi-Fi password and your plug’s eWeLink keys in plain text.
• Do not attach a Sonoff backup, or any part of one, to an issue or pull request. Describe what you see instead, for example the offsets and sizes involved, the Sonoff version and the log lines. A pull request that adds Sonoff firmware or code taken from it will not be accepted.
• Use a backup only on the plug it came from.